Larry makes his mom’s golden, airy popovers skillfully. Some recipes in our household are his alone, and this is definitely one. If I proclaimed a decision to make some popovers, fuggeddaboudit. Not allowed. He has his giant binder of recipes and I have mine.
My mother-in-law, Thelma is now 88 and doesn’t cook anymore. A 50s kind of home cook, she was a SAHM for three kids and homemaker for husband, Elmer. Could those two names – Thelma Daisy and Elmer Morris – be any funnier? Both born in Los Angeles, which doesn’t seem to fit in our opinions.
Larry’s binder includes several index cards in his mom’s schoolbook-pretty handwriting. Her popover recipe is simple, but outcome can be a little finicky if the weather isn’t right. Today, perfect weather. I think our monster gas oven bakes a better popover than our dainty electric – if you ever remodel, add both and you won’t regret it. Plus, the secret weapon that cinches it: a tin with the right depth and slope for batter to POP.
Only four little ingredients and three short sentences produce crispy goodness. Eat ‘em fast – Larry tops his with applesauce and cinnamon. Mine plain.
Thelma’s Popovers
- 1 cup flour
- 1/2 tsp. salt
- 1 cup milk
- 2 eggs, room temperature
Mix all ingredients. Put in well-greased muffin pans* half full. Bake 400 degrees F. for 35 minutes.












{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }
I love popovers more than life itself. I grew up eating them at the Jordan Pond House in Bar Harbor, Maine. So delicious. Popover pans are pretty easy to find; Williams-Sonoma sells them. And yes, they definitely need to be consumed immediately! With butter! With jam! They’re also delicious savory – add some grated cheese to the top before you put them in the oven. Yum! Thanks for posting the recipe and the sweet story about your mother-in-law.
wow! sounds doable, i have to try this asap
Question: do you have to eat these right away or are they still ok the next day?
Patti comments: eat right away. They get rubbery quickly. I ate a two-day-old one this morning and not so good.
I had no idea popovers were so simple or else I would’ve made them ages ago! Thanks!
These are beautiful! WHERE did you ever find a popover pan? Nice lighting too!
Patti comments: Larry bought the pan at a gourmet cookware shop, most likely Sur la Table in Santa Monica, CA.
I haven’t made a popover since Home Ec class in high school, and they never looked this good.